Image Source: Kompass Solutions

During 2024 and early 2025, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) refused a substantial number of food product shipments from India. According to the FDA’s import refusal data (Jan 2024 to Apr 2025), there were approximately 2,687 line-item refusals of Indian-origin food products in this period. These refusals span a wide range of product categories – from spices and snacks to grains, oils, fruits, and more, essentially covering all major Indian food export categories. Each refusal represents a shipment line detained and ultimately denied entry into the US due to regulatory violations. Below, we explore the trends, key products and companies, common violation reasons, and the broader patterns and implications for Indian exporters.

Trends from 2024-25

Monthly Refusal Trends:

In early 2024, FDA refusals of Indian food products were relatively moderate (roughly 80 to 120 per month). However, starting mid-2024 the refusals surged, doubling by July 2024 and continuing to rise through the fall. The data show notable spikes in September 2024 (236 refusals) and November 2024 (340 refusals), the latter being the peak month. The trend then eased slightly in early 2025, but monthly refusals remained higher than early 2024 levels. This indicates that late 2024 saw significantly intensified enforcement or increased non-compliance issues for Indian exports. Possible factors include the FDA cracking down on specific violations or import alerts targeting certain exporters.

Notable Spikes:

The sharp jump in refusals in late 2024 correlates with several enforcement actions. Certain high-profile Indian food firms were placed on Import Alert during this time, leading to the blanket detention of their shipments. One major Indian snack manufacturer accounted for over 200 refusals in November 2024 alone after the FDA found its products were manufactured under unsanitary conditions. Such firm-specific enforcement contributed heavily to the late-2024 spike. Additionally, there were ongoing issues with Indian spice exporters during this period. Heightened scrutiny of spices and other commodities likely also added to the increased refusal counts in late 2024.

Refusals by Product Category

Indian food export refusals spanned virtually all categories of foods. Several categories stand out:

1. Prepared or Packaged Foods: Approximately 119 refusals in a miscellaneous prepared foods category. Multi-ingredient products, sweets, and other processed foods round out the categories
2. Snack Foods (Savoury Snacks): This was the largest category with approximately 576 refusals. Many traditional Indian snack products were refused. The unusually high count here is largely attributable to one major snack manufacturer whose products were detained en masse under an import alert due to manufacturing practice violations
3. Spices and Seasonings: India, being the world’s largest spice exporter, saw many spice shipments refused. Approximately 320 refusals were in the spices or flavourings category. Contamination issues, such as pathogens like Salmonella or excessive pesticide residues, were a known problem during this period
4. Cereal Grains (Rice) and Pulses: Grain products (including basmati rice, flours) accounted for about 289 refusals, and dried lentils or legumes another 240. These staples were often flagged for issues like pesticide residue violations or contamination.
5. Bakery or Baked Goods: Approximately 212 refusals. Products such as breads, biscuits, and other baked goods were refused, often due to labelling issues or ingredient non-compliance.
6. Noodles and Pasta: Around 208 refusals. Instant noodles and similar products were another significant category, again likely tied to labelling and possibly additive violations.
7. Edible Seeds and Nuts (e.g. Betel Nut): Around 205 refusals. Betel nut (areca nut) is a notable Indian export in this category. Many betel nut shipments were refused, possibly for filth (insect infestation) or Salmonella.
8. Fruits and Vegetables: Indian tropical fruits and vegetable products also saw dozens of refusals. Common issues here include excessive pesticide residues and improper labelling.

Common Reasons for Refusal and Violations

Every FDA refusal is accompanied by one or more cited violation charges. Several clear themes emerge:

• Pathogen Contamination (Salmonella): The single most common citation was Salmonella, appearing 493 times. This means hundreds of Indian food shipments (especially spices and botanical products) tested positive for Salmonella bacteria.
• Unsanitary Processing or Facilities: This shows up via two related codes indicating the product appears to have been prepared, packed, or held under insanitary conditions. These charges are typically invoked when the FDA has evidence that a producer’s facility has poor hygiene, pest infestations, or a lack of controls.
• Pesticide Residues (Illegal Chemicals): This refers to foods containing unsafe pesticide chemical residues. Many Indian agricultural products were found with pesticide levels above US tolerances or with completely unapproved pesticides.
• Filth and Unsanitary Contents: A significant number of Indian shipments contained visible filth or infestation, failing US standards. This ties back to the need for better cleaning, sorting, and pest control in the supply chain.
• Labelling and Misbranding Issues: The FDA also refused many products for labelling non-compliance. These refer to misbranding under US law – e.g. missing or incorrect nutrition facts panels, or not listing ingredients in English.
• Unsafe Additives or Adulterants: These indicate the presence of unapproved food additives or colourants in the product.
• FSVP Non-Compliance: A notable regulatory reason was FSVP violations. FSVP stands for Foreign Supplier Verification Program. A citation here means the shipment was refused because the US importer did not have a proper FSVP in place for that food.

In summary, contamination, chemical residues, and labelling deficiencies were the primary culprits behind most refusals. These align with global observations that safety and labelling are the two pillars of import compliance.

Patterns, Causes, and Implications for Exporters

1. Systemic Quality Control Gaps: The recurrence of Salmonella and filth in spices, for example, points to inadequate sanitary controls. Pesticide residue issues imply that export-bound crops are not always meeting international standards.
2. Regulatory Enforcement and Import Alerts: The surge in late 2024 refusals underscores how FDA enforcement actions can dramatically impact trade. The implication for exporters is clear: a single violation or outbreak can trigger intense scrutiny or an import alert that blocks all products.
3. Documentation and Compliance: Not all refusals were due to inherent product hazards. A substantial number were preventable compliance issues. The prevalence of labelling refusals suggests many exporters did not invest in understanding US labelling rules. Similarly, the FSVP-related refusals highlight a regulatory nuance.
4. Impact and Future Outlook: The high refusal numbers in 2024 carry some regulatory implications for India’s food industry. Indian spice exporters, in particular, might need to adopt international best practices to reduce contamination.

Key Takeaways and the Road Ahead for Indian Food Exporters

The 2024 to 2025 FDA import refusal data for Indian food products paints a mixed picture. India’s diverse food exports continue to reach the US, but significant portions are being turned away due to safety and compliance problems. Indian exporters must internalize US FDA requirements and invest in compliance to avoid refusals. Recognizing these problem areas provides a roadmap for improvement. By addressing the root causes, Indian companies can reduce refusals and strengthen their image as providers of safe, high-quality foods. The onus is on exporters to keep pace with evolving regulations. Those that do so will find a more sustainable and successful export trajectory.

—————— Ankit Kankar (ankit.kankar@mmactiv.com)